Unpacking the Earnings Mystery: Western Alliance Inc’s Price Signals
Western Alliance Bancorporation (NYSE: WAL), a Phoenix-based regional bank, has seen its stock price fluctuate dramatically in 2023, leaving investors questioning what its valuation truly signals about future earnings potential. As of late October, shares trade near $45—a 30% rebound from March lows but still 25% below pre-2023 banking crisis levels. Analysts remain divided on whether current prices reflect an undervalued opportunity or accurately price in looming risks.
The Price-to-Earnings Puzzle
Western Alliance currently trades at a forward P/E ratio of 6.8, significantly below the S&P 500 regional bank average of 10.2. This discount persists despite the bank reporting:
- Q3 2023 net income of $215.4 million ($1.96 per diluted share)
- Total deposits growth to $53.6 billion (up 5% quarter-over-quarter)
- Net interest margin stabilization at 3.45%
“The market is applying a crisis-era multiple to what’s actually a recovery story,” contends financial analyst Miranda Cheng of Bernstein Research. “Either Wall Street knows something the financials don’t show yet, or this represents one of the more compelling value plays in midsize banking.”
Deposit Stability vs. Commercial Real Estate Exposure
Two competing narratives dominate the Western Alliance investment thesis. Bullish investors highlight the bank’s success in rebuilding deposits after March’s regional banking turmoil. CEO Kenneth Vecchione emphasized during the Q3 earnings call that “insured deposits now represent 73% of our total, up from 55% at year-end 2022.”
However, bears point to the bank’s $9.2 billion commercial real estate (CRE) loan portfolio—23% of total loans—as a potential earnings drag. With office vacancy rates exceeding 18% nationally and $1.5 trillion in CRE debt maturing through 2025, skeptics question whether current provisions adequately reflect risk.
“Western Alliance’s heavy exposure to Arizona and California commercial properties could become problematic,” warns banking risk consultant David Park. “While their underwriting standards are solid, regional banks often feel sector downturns more acutely than money centers.”
What the Technicals Reveal About Investor Sentiment
Chart patterns tell their own story. Since March’s volatility, WAL shares have established:
- Support at $38 (tested three times without breaking)
- Resistance near $52 (the post-crisis high from August)
- Declining short interest (down to 8.5% of float from 22% in May)
The options market shows growing confidence, with the put/call ratio dropping to 0.65—its lowest level since February 2023. Meanwhile, institutional ownership has rebounded to 82%, slightly above pre-crisis levels.
Comparing Peer Valuations
Western Alliance’s discounted valuation becomes more intriguing when compared to similar regional banks:
| Bank | Forward P/E | Price/Book | ROE (TTM) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Western Alliance | 6.8 | 0.92 | 12.4% |
| East West Bancorp | 8.1 | 1.15 | 14.1% |
| Zions Bancorp | 7.3 | 0.87 | 10.8% |
This discrepancy suggests either market skepticism about WAL’s earnings quality or a mispricing opportunity. Notably, Western Alliance’s return on equity (ROE) remains competitive despite its lower multiples.
The Interest Rate Wildcard
Federal Reserve policy remains the joker in the deck. While higher-for-longer rates initially benefit net interest margins, they also:
- Increase funding costs as banks compete for deposits
- Pressure loan demand, particularly in commercial segments
- Elevate risks for variable-rate borrowers
Western Alliance’s earnings sensitivity analysis suggests each 25-basis-point Fed hike adds $18-22 million to annual net interest income. However, this benefit could reverse quickly if economic weakness forces rate cuts in 2024.
Management’s Strategic Moves
Executives have taken proactive steps to shore up confidence:
- Reduced wholesale funding reliance from 28% to 11% of liabilities
- Increased liquidity coverage ratio to 135%
- Maintained conservative loan-to-deposit ratio of 85%
CFO Dale Gibbons noted during a recent investor presentation that “we’ve intentionally slowed loan growth to maintain balance sheet flexibility.” This cautious approach may explain why earnings growth has moderated from 2022’s 28% pace to a projected 8-10% for full-year 2023.
Looking Ahead: Three Potential Scenarios
Analysts outline divergent paths for Western Alliance’s stock based on earnings trajectory:
- Bull Case ($60+): CRE concerns prove overblown, Fed achieves soft landing, and WAL returns to 15% earnings growth by 2025
- Base Case ($45-55): Moderate credit deterioration offsets NII gains, resulting in mid-single-digit EPS growth
- Bear Case (<$35): Commercial real estate losses spike, forcing significant provision increases and potential dividend cut
The bank’s upcoming Q4 earnings report (expected January 18) could provide crucial clues about which scenario appears most likely. Investors should particularly monitor:
- Non-performing loan trends
- Deposit cost trajectory
- Updated guidance on net interest margin
For those considering a position, dollar-cost averaging may prove prudent given ongoing sector volatility. As always with regional banks, thorough due diligence remains essential—these institutions often present both exceptional opportunities and unique risks.
Market participants seeking exposure to the regional banking recovery might find Western Alliance’s current valuation compelling, but should weigh the stock’s discounted multiples against legitimate sector headwinds. The coming quarters will reveal whether today’s price truly reflects an earnings mystery or a market misjudgment.
See more CNBC Network
