The Unbreakable Bonds: Why Japanese and Middle Eastern Banks Stand by Adani Group

The global banking sector has witnessed a significant shift in its relationship with Adani Group, one of India’s largest and most controversial conglomerates. Despite scrutiny and increasing concerns from Western financial institutions, Japanese and Middle Eastern banks continue to support Adani Group, raising important questions about the strategies, risk assessments, and geopolitical dynamics that drive these decisions. This article explores the enduring support of Adani Group by these financial institutions, compares it with the hesitations of Western banks, and delves into the broader implications of these differing approaches.

Background: The Rise of Adani Group

Founded in 1988 by Gautam Adani, the Adani Group has grown into one of India’s largest and most diversified business conglomerates, with interests spanning energy, infrastructure, logistics, mining, and more. The Group’s rapid expansion has been fueled by aggressive investments and a business model that capitalizes on India’s infrastructure boom and growing demand for energy. With a market capitalization that once positioned it as one of the world’s most valuable companies, Adani Group has attracted significant attention—both positive and negative.

However, recent controversies surrounding the Adani Group’s financial practices, environmental impact, and corporate governance have raised alarms among investors, regulators, and financial institutions worldwide. The most significant of these concerns has been the allegations raised by a short-seller report from Hindenburg Research in early 2023, which accused the Group of stock manipulation, financial irregularities, and environmental violations. These accusations have led to sharp fluctuations in the Group’s stock prices, prompting increased scrutiny from global financial bodies.

The Continued Support from Japanese Banks

In stark contrast to their Western counterparts, Japanese financial institutions have maintained their support for Adani Group despite the growing controversy. Major Japanese banks, including Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group (MUFG), Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corporation (SMBC), and Mizuho Financial Group, are among the key lenders to the Adani Group.

Strategic Interests in India and Asia

One of the primary reasons behind the continued backing of Adani by Japanese banks is the long-term strategic interests these banks have in India and the broader Asian market. India, with its fast-growing economy, is a crucial market for Japanese companies and banks. Adani Group’s expansive business portfolio aligns well with Japan’s interests in areas such as energy, infrastructure, and mining, all of which are sectors that Japan has heavily invested in to bolster its own economic and geopolitical standing in Asia.

Moreover, Japan has increasingly focused on fostering closer economic ties with India as part of its broader strategy to counterbalance China’s growing influence in the region. By supporting a prominent Indian conglomerate like Adani, Japanese banks are not just backing a business but are also reinforcing diplomatic and economic ties between the two nations.

Risk Tolerance and Diversification Strategies

Another factor influencing Japanese banks’ decisions is their relatively higher risk tolerance in emerging markets. Japanese financial institutions have a long history of supporting large-scale infrastructure projects in Asia and other developing regions. These projects often carry higher risks but also offer significant rewards, particularly in the form of long-term returns from stable, high-demand sectors like energy and transportation.

Japanese banks are also known for their diversified portfolios. Their support for Adani Group is part of a broader strategy to invest in a range of sectors across different regions, minimizing the overall risk exposure. The ongoing growth of India’s infrastructure and energy sectors offers these banks a solid long-term outlook, which may justify their continued support despite short-term volatility.

Middle Eastern Banks and the Geopolitical Landscape

Similarly, several Middle Eastern banks have also played a significant role in financing Adani Group’s ventures. The UAE’s Emirates NBD and Qatar National Bank (QNB) are among those that have extended financial backing to Adani. The Middle East’s relationship with Adani is not purely based on economic calculations, but also deeply intertwined with regional geopolitics and energy interests.

Energy Ties and Regional Economic Integration

The Middle East, particularly the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries, has a vested interest in the global energy market. Adani Group’s significant role in the Indian energy sector, particularly through its coal and renewable energy operations, makes it an attractive partner for Middle Eastern investors. As major oil-exporting nations, GCC countries are keen on diversifying their portfolios into non-oil sectors, including renewable energy and infrastructure projects.

Furthermore, the Middle East has been shifting its focus towards greater economic integration with South Asia. India’s growing energy needs and its increasing role in the global economy present significant opportunities for Middle Eastern nations to establish stronger economic and financial ties with the subcontinent. Adani Group, as a key player in India’s energy sector, offers a vehicle for these nations to gain a foothold in this expanding market.

Political and Economic Considerations

For many Middle Eastern banks, their decision to continue backing Adani also ties into broader political considerations. The Middle East has historically fostered strong economic relations with India, and lending to large Indian corporations is seen as a way to cement those relationships. Adani Group, with its close ties to the Indian government, is a politically influential player, and supporting such a conglomerate may be seen as an effective way to maintain diplomatic and economic leverage in a region that is increasingly important to global energy markets.

Why Western Banks Are Hesitant

In contrast to the unwavering support from Japanese and Middle Eastern banks, many Western financial institutions have taken a more cautious approach to Adani Group. Some major U.S. and European banks have pulled back from providing funding or have significantly reduced their exposure to the conglomerate, citing concerns about corporate governance, financial transparency, and environmental risks.

Scrutiny and Regulatory Pressure

Western banks, particularly those operating in the U.S. and Europe, are often subject to more stringent regulatory frameworks that emphasize environmental, social, and governance (ESG) criteria. The accusations of environmental degradation linked to Adani Group’s coal operations and other ventures have been a major red flag for these institutions. Reports on the Group’s alleged financial irregularities have also raised alarms about its compliance with international financial reporting standards, prompting many Western banks to distance themselves.

Public Perception and Ethical Considerations

Western financial institutions are also under greater public scrutiny when it comes to ethical investments. With a growing focus on ESG issues, many banks in Europe and the U.S. are increasingly hesitant to engage with companies that have been accused of unethical practices. The Adani Group’s controversies have sparked widespread protests, and continuing to lend to or support the Group could expose banks to reputational risks in their home markets.

The Broader Implications

The divergent approaches of Japanese, Middle Eastern, and Western banks in their dealings with Adani Group highlight important global trends in finance, geopolitics, and sustainability. These differing perspectives underscore the complex balance between financial risk, ethical considerations, and long-term strategic interests in today’s interconnected world.

• Geopolitical Strategy: Countries like Japan and those in the Middle East may view support for Adani as part of a broader geopolitical strategy to strengthen ties with India and diversify their economic interests.
• Risk Management: Japanese and Middle Eastern banks have demonstrated a higher tolerance for risk in emerging markets, which allows them to continue supporting Adani despite the volatility.
• Western Caution: The West’s heightened focus on corporate governance and ESG criteria has led to greater caution, resulting in some institutions distancing themselves from Adani.

Conclusion

The ongoing support of Adani Group by Japanese and Middle Eastern banks reflects a complex interplay of economic, geopolitical, and strategic factors. These institutions are betting on the long-term potential of India’s growth and the broader Asian market, despite the risks associated with Adani’s financial practices and environmental record. Meanwhile, Western banks’ hesitations point to a growing emphasis on transparency, governance, and ethical considerations in global finance. The situation raises broader questions about the future of international banking relationships, as well as the role of financial institutions in promoting sustainability and ethical practices in an increasingly globalized world.

As the global financial landscape evolves, it remains to be seen whether the continued backing of Adani by non-Western banks will withstand the pressures of increasing regulatory scrutiny, public opinion, and global market volatility.

BBC News | Reuters
See more CNBC Network